Comparison

positiveEats vs Water Tracker

Price, ratings, monetisation and update history for both apps, side by side β€” with what reviewers say about each.

Head to head
About

positiveEats

Features
Read full description

A study shows 97% users abandon food journal apps within a week. If you are one of the 3%, stop reading now. Why are they so hard to use? First, they throw up too many roadblocks to the straightforward task of logging food. Second, they have a reductionist view of food. They turn food into a tally of nutrients, ignoring its broader context. Ironically, it actually takes more work. PositiveEats is based on the Positive Eating Plan, which employs science to eliminate worries, not to introduce them. When you open PositiveEats, you start logging food with the first tap. There is no need to create an account, complete a questionnaire about your weight loss goals (or emotions), or decline trial offers. Logging a cup of black coffee requires just three taps, while recording a more complex dish like a baked egg recipe with onion, tomato, spinach, eggs, and pesto takes only nine. Other apps, by contrast, would demand that you create a custom recipe for the dish, and a sub-recipe for the pesto. Simplicity is the greatest feature of PositiveEats. Mark Twain once said that he didn't have time to write a short letter, so he wrote a long one. The Positive Eating Plan is the short list of rules that result from taking the time to think through the science. Key features of the plan include: 1. It's positive. Telling people not to do the wrong thing doesn't get them to do the right thing. The Positive Eating Plan emphasizes filling up on the right foods, thus reducing the temptation to eat the wrong ones. The goal for each category is the minimum you need to eat, not the maximum you can eat. 2. It tracks food in broad categories. While a balanced diet with variety is essential, food tracking need not be overly granular. Whether you ate a peach or an apple matters little in the broader scheme of a varied diet. Similarly, whether your bread is whole wheat or white is of less consequence if bread plays a minor role in an otherwise balanced diet. Tracking six broad categories of food offers a more nuanced view of your diet than a single calorie count. 3. It tracks real food, not nutrients. Real foods offer benefits beyond the sum of their nutrients. Scientific studies demonstrate that vitamin A supplements, for example, do not replicate the benefits of consuming carrots. Nutrients interact differently within whole foods, as evidenced by the higher absorption of fructose from orange juice compared to whole oranges. 4. It tracks weight, not calories. Calorie tracking often requires weighing food, identifying it precisely, and looking it up in a databaseβ€”a process fraught with complexity. The USDA database, for instance, lists over 1,000 entries for French fries alone, with calorie counts varying by as much as 100 kcal for small servings. This complexity often leads to frustration and abandonment of the effort. 5. It leaves room for you to eat freely. You don't have to swear off ice cream. Balance, mental and nutritional, is key to sustainable eating habits. PositiveEats and its underlying Positive Eating Plan simplify the process of food logging, making it accessible, manageable, and ultimately, more effective.

About

Water Tracker

Features
Read full description

Hydration, made fluid. Most trackers turn a glass of water into paperwork. IdroFlow does the opposite β€” it gets out of the way. One tap, and the day moves on. The whole app is built from restrained glass surfaces that let your progress show through, with motion that behaves like the thing it is tracking. Clear, quiet, and calm enough to keep using on the days you would rather not think about it. A tap is the whole ritual Your usual drinks are waiting where you left them. Tap one and it is logged β€” no forms, no sliders, no arguing with a keyboard. Water, coffee, tea, or something you named yourself, in the amount you actually drink. Logging should cost you nothing, so it costs you a second. The numbers tell the truth Not every drink hydrates the same way, and IdroFlow does not pretend otherwise. A 350 ml coffee counts for what it really contributes, and the arithmetic happens on screen where you can see it. One honest goal, instead of a dashboard to manage. Reminders with a sense of timing Choose the hours that suit your day and they stay out of the rest of it. Reach your goal and they stop until tomorrow. Nothing buzzes just to prove the app is still installed. Where you already are Log from Apple Watch with the Digital Crown, with or without your iPhone nearby β€” including after a workout, when it matters most. Keep today on your Home Screen and Lock Screen, or just ask Siri. Water and sparkling water flow through to Apple Health, and everything you log follows you between devices through your own iCloud account. New in 2.0 Today, Timeline and Insights have been rebuilt around one idea: hydration, made fluid. The same calm surface across iPhone, iPad and Apple Watch. Insights read the rhythm of your recent days and tell you what actually changed β€” not what a chart looks like. IdroFlow Plus Custom drinks with your own names, colors and hydration values. Up to eight quick-add buttons. Adaptive reminders that follow how your days usually go. The complete set of insights. Extra widgets and Watch complications. And, if your device supports it, logging from a photo or by writing what you drank β€” both use Apple Intelligence, and need a compatible device, an up-to-date iOS and a supported language. No ads, and no account to create. What you drink stays yours β€” it lives in your own iCloud and Apple Health, and nobody at IdroFlow can see it. IdroFlow Plus is available as an in-app purchase. Terms of Use (EULA): https://www.apple.com/legal/internet-services/itunes/dev/stdeula/ Privacy Policy: https://federicotrevisani.dev/idroflow/privacy

Screenshots

positiveEats4 screens
Water Tracker4 screens

Verdict

The call

The clearest difference is in-app purchases: positiveEats at none against Water Tracker's 3. positiveEats also leads on iOS requirement (15.0 vs 26.0). Water Tracker's advantage is ads (none vs shown) and device support (4 vs 2). On price there is nothing between them.

Scored on Price Β· Rating Β· Positive reviews Β· Number of ratings Β· Update frequency Β· Ads Β· In-app purchases Β· Monetization Β· Best chart rank Β· Devices Β· Requires iOS

CostPrice Β· In-app purchases Β· Ads Β· Monetization

Both are free to download. Water Tracker sells 3 in-app purchases, starting at $1.99 per month. positiveEats asks for nothing beyond the download.

Scorecard4 real differences Β· 2 level
positiveEats versus Water Tracker: the parameters behind the verdict, then further details
ParameterpositiveEatsWater Tracker
PriceFreeFree
Update frequencyβ€”Every 9 days
AdsYesNo β€” better
In-app purchasesNo β€” betterYes
DevicesiPhone, iPodiPhone, iPad, Mac, Apple Watch β€” better
Requires iOS15.0 β€” better26.0
Further details β€” not scored
Size17 MB90 MB
Age rating4+4+
DeveloperMicromiriFederico Trevisani

In-app purchases

None

positiveEats

No in-app purchases

3 purchases

Water Tracker

Subscriptions2
  • IdroFlow Plus$1.991 Month
  • IdroFlow Plus (Annual)7 Days trial$7.991 Year
One-time1
  • IdroFlow Plus (Lifetime)$19.99

Questions

Is positiveEats free?
positiveEats is free to download, with no in-app purchases.
Is Water Tracker free?
Water Tracker is free to download, with in-app purchases available.
Do positiveEats or Water Tracker have ads?
positiveEats shows ads; Water Tracker does not.

Other comparisons