RetireSmartIRA vs ToRothorNot
Price, ratings, monetisation and update history for both apps, side by side — with what reviewers say about each.
RetireSmartIRA
Plan and manage retirement taxes with real-time financial modeling. Analyze Roth conversions, Social Security claiming, RMDs, and Medicare surcharges. Offers detailed projections and scenario building for informed financial decisions.
- Roth conversion analysis
- Social Security claiming strategy
- RMD projections
- IRMAA and ACA cliff impact
- Scenario builder with real-time updates
- Detailed tax waterfall visualization
Read full descriptionHide full description
Plan your retirement taxes like a pro — this year, next year, and across retirement. RetireSmartIRA helps you model the tax decisions usually scattered across spreadsheets, IRS worksheets, and CPA meetings: Roth conversions, Social Security timing, RMDs, IRMAA, the ACA cliff, and more. It's built for the financially engaged: people who want to understand their numbers, not just be told what to do. No spreadsheets, no black boxes: every dollar traces back to the input that produced it. ANSWER THE QUESTIONS THAT ACTUALLY MATTER • What will I owe this year? Estimate federal tax, state tax, NIIT, IRMAA, ACA effects, and withholding needs before tax time. • How much should I convert to Roth this year, and over time? Build a multi-year conversion ladder instead of guessing. • When should my spouse and I claim Social Security? Compare claiming strategies across both lifetimes and survivor outcomes. • Which year should I make a major charitable gift? Test gift timing against conversions and your projected tax bill. • What does my family actually keep? Compare your lifetime taxes with what heirs may owe on inherited IRA assets. MULTI-YEAR TAX PLAN The Multi-Year Plan builds a Roth conversion strategy across your retirement horizon, then lets you choose how to convert: minimize lifetime tax, fill to a target tax bracket, or stay under a Medicare IRMAA tier. Compare the approaches side by side. Choose how each year's conversion tax is paid, and enter wages and pension income year by year for either spouse. See the projected impact on lifetime taxes, ending IRA and Roth balances, future RMDs, IRMAA exposure, and inherited-account taxes. Model charitable giving (QCDs and cash gifts), adjust any year, review the assumptions, and export a CPA-ready briefing. SCENARIO BUILDER: PLAN IN REAL TIME Test Roth conversions, withdrawals, QCDs, charitable gifts, withholding, and Social Security changes before you act. One screen shows federal tax (2026 brackets), state tax (all 50 states + DC), NIIT, IRMAA surcharges, ACA effects, standard vs. itemized with SALT cap math, and taxable brokerage income. See the cost of each converted dollar: every bracket, state step, and surcharge named where it begins. QUARTERLY ESTIMATED TAXES Record what you have paid: a payment ledger with dates and federal and state amounts, measured against each IRS due date and your safe-harbor target. Withholding counts across the year the way the IRS credits it, and your coverage prints in the report. RETIREMENT DRAWDOWN Project how your IRA and 401(k) balances spend down over 40 years: RMDs only, a target spending level, or a withdrawal rate. See when your income reaches the first Medicare IRMAA tier, in future or today's dollars. SOCIAL SECURITY COUPLES PLANNER Compare claiming at 62 vs. FRA vs. 70 for both spouses, with lifetime benefits and survivor protection side by side. RMD CALCULATOR FOR YOUR IRA AND INHERITED IRAs Most calculators get inherited IRAs wrong. RetireSmartIRA handles RMDs at 73 (or 75 under SECURE 2.0), spousal inherited IRAs, the 10-year rule, and stretch options for eligible beneficiaries. WHO IT'S FOR • Anyone doing this year's retirement tax planning: conversions, withdrawals, charitable gifts, withholding • Pre-retirees mapping out a multi-year Roth conversion strategy • Retirees managing RMDs, IRMAA, and the ACA cliff • Anyone with a government pension, 457 or 403(b) whose state taxes it differently • Federal/military households (FERS, military retirement, VA Disability) ALWAYS CURRENT Every IRS limit, HHS poverty guideline, ACA threshold, and Medicare bracket reflects 2026 values. State tax data is verified against each state's own published forms, and every state shows the date it was last checked and the sources behind it. PRIVATE BY DESIGN Your financial data never leaves your device: no cloud accounts, no data harvesting, no ads, no subscriptions. BUILT FOR APPLE Native iPhone, iPad, and Mac app. Free on all three.
ToRothorNot
This app helps you evaluate Roth conversion strategies and their impact on your retirement. It allows you to compare different scenarios, test Social Security claiming choices, and model various financial factors for individuals and married households.
- Roth conversion strategy evaluation
- Social Security claiming analysis
- Scenario comparison
- Married household modeling
- ACA subsidy impact exploration
- Dynamic 'what-if' analysis
Read full descriptionHide full description
ToRothorNot helps you evaluate Roth conversion strategies and see how they may affect your retirement savings and draw-downs. Enter your Traditional IRA balance, tax-related inputs, and up to three custom scenarios to compare projected net worth at your chosen target age, end net worth, cumulative costs, and other key planning outcomes. Test Social Security claiming choices and compare scenarios side by side. Interactive charts let you view net worth or differences between strategies, zoom in, and highlight individual strategies. The app also supports married households, including survivor-spouse modeling and separate spouse Social Security timing. Premium unlocks Computed Strategies that automatically test approaches such as No Conversions, Balanced Conversions, Best End Net Worth Found, optimization for net worth at your selected target age, and more. Premium also adds heir-focused comparisons, PDF export of the Summary, CSV export of detailed Results, and dynamic Explore tools for what-if analysis. Explore lets you adjust conversion amounts, Social Security timing, spending, investment growth, annual QCDs, and other planning inputs to see results change. For ACA users, subsidy-aware exploration shows how key income inputs may affect ACA costs and subsidies. Birth month and year inputs refine Social Security, Medicare, and QCD timing, while RMD starting ages follow birth-year rules. Choose standard or custom deductions and adjust the tax inflation assumption, which defaults to 2.5%, to project growth in tax brackets, standard deductions, selected limits, and ACA premiums. ToRothorNot models a broad range of factors, including federal tax brackets, Social Security taxation, the enhanced Senior Deduction, IRMAA surcharges, NIIT, AMT, ACA premiums and subsidies, capital gains taxation, QCDs, and survivor-spouse timing effects. Projections use 2026 federal tax tables and related limits as their starting point. Future indexed amounts are planning estimates, and the app is intended to be updated annually to reflect tax-law and threshold changes. This is an educational planning tool and does not model every IRS worksheet or edge case. It does not guarantee the absolute best strategy, but it can be a practical way to evaluate tradeoffs and prepare for conversations with your advisor.
Screenshots
Verdict
The clearest difference is in-app purchases: RetireSmartIRA at none against ToRothorNot's 1. RetireSmartIRA also leads on update cadence (every 6 days vs every 2 weeks) and ratings volume (16 vs 4). ToRothorNot's advantage is rating (5.0 vs 4.6) and review sentiment (100% vs 86%). On price, ads, device support and iOS requirement there is nothing between them.
Scored on Price · Rating · Positive reviews · Number of ratings · Update frequency · Ads · In-app purchases · Monetization · Best chart rank · Devices · Requires iOS
Both are free to download. ToRothorNot sells 1 one-off in-app purchase. RetireSmartIRA asks for nothing beyond the download.
ToRothorNot holds the better App Store score, 5.0 against 4.6. Both are backed by a comparable volume of ratings — 16 and 4 respectively. Written reviews point the same way: 86% of RetireSmartIRA's written reviews are positive against 100% of ToRothorNot's.
RetireSmartIRA ships an update every 6 days, ToRothorNot every 2 weeks. The most recent releases landed on November 13, 2026 and November 17, 2026 respectively.
| Parameter | RetireSmartIRA | ToRothorNot |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free | Free |
| Rating | 4.6 (16 ratings) | 5.0 (4 ratings) — better |
| Positive reviews | 85.7% of reviews | 100.0% of reviews — better |
| Number of ratings | 16 — better | 4 |
| Update frequency | Every 6 days — better | Every 2 weeks |
| Ads | No | No |
| In-app purchases | No — better | Yes |
| Monetization | Free — better | Free with in-app purchases |
| Devices | iPhone, iPad, Mac — better | iPhone, iPad |
| Requires iOS | 18.6 | 18.6 |
| Further details — not scored | ||
| Size | 13 MB | 5 MB |
| Age rating | 4+ | 4+ |
| Developer | John Urban | Orestes Melgarejo |
Customer experience
RetireSmartIRA
ToRothorNot
In-app purchases
RetireSmartIRA
No in-app purchases
ToRothorNot
- Premium Unlock$19.99
Questions
Is RetireSmartIRA free?
Is ToRothorNot free?
Which has better reviews, RetireSmartIRA or ToRothorNot?
Do RetireSmartIRA or ToRothorNot have ads?
Which is updated more often, RetireSmartIRA or ToRothorNot?
Other comparisons















