Comparison

MurMur vs Idle Haystack

Price, ratings, monetisation and update history for both games, side by side — with what reviewers say about each.

Head to head
About

MurMur

Features
Read full description

An idle swarm colony game for anyone who wants relaxing progress in short sessions. Tap anywhere and a single explorer heads there; the swarm follows, grows and flows like a river. Each season lasts one to three minutes, and you come back stronger. TIRED OF IDLE GAMES THAT FEEL LIKE WORK? Most incremental games bury you in timers, energy bars and tycoon menus. You tap a button, watch a number, and wait. Relaxing games, on the other hand, often have nothing to work towards. MurMur sits in between: quiet enough to rest your mind, deep enough to keep your colony growing. ONE BECOMES RIVER Touch anywhere on the screen and your explorer heads there. The swarm follows. Eat food pools and new units are born, one after another, until a handful of sparks becomes a colony and the colony flows like a river across the dark. Charge a five-second Stampede when you want to go faster. A season is short, so there is always time for one more. SEASONS END. PHEROMONE STAYS. When a season ends, food resets and your swarm rests. What you keep is pheromone, and pheromone is permanent. Spend it in the Hive on upgrades that carry into every future season. Nothing is lost. Your first season back is around ten times faster, so every reset feels like a reward instead of a restart. WHAT YOU CAN DO • Steer the swarm directly with one tap. It is idle, but never passive. • Grow through five phases, from a lone explorer to a full Continent. • Build the Hive your way with three branches: Flow for boost, Hunger for food, Memory for seasons and time away. • Migrate to new biomes on the map. Each one multiplies your food and opens a new chapter. • Keep moving while you are away. Your swarm carries on when the game is closed and shows you what it gathered when you return. • Collect journal lines, badges and ranks as the story of your colony unfolds. • Unlock quirk skins that change how the swarm behaves, how its trail looks and which palette it glows in. • Follow your records: time in the river, seasons played, largest swarm per season. FAIR BY DESIGN No power is sold. Every upgrade is earned in play. Skins are quirks, not power. Ads are optional and only appear when you choose to double a reward. There is no account to create and your progress saves locally on your device. MADE TO BE COMFORTABLE Neon colors on a dark background, one typeface and a few quiet words. Turn on reduced motion, lower the swarm density, or highlight the nearest food pool. Adjust sound, haptics and number format whenever you like. WHO IS IT FOR? • Players who love idle and incremental games and the pleasure of watching a colony grow. • Anyone looking for a relaxing moment on a commute, in a break or before sleep. • People who can watch a murmuration of starlings for an hour and want to guide one themselves. • Collectors who want every badge, every journal line and every quirk. START WITH ONE MurMur is free to download and takes about ten seconds to begin. Tap once, find the first pool and watch what follows you. One explorer, then the river. Start your first season today.

About

Idle Haystack

Features
Read full description

There is a needle in this haystack. There is a needle in the next one too. Tap the stack. Straws fly. Somewhere in there is a needle, and the only way to find out where is to keep digging. FIND THE NEEDLE Every haystack hides one needle somewhere between a third of the way down and the very bottom. Sometimes you get lucky on the tenth tap. Sometimes you earn every single straw. HIRE HELP Farmhands, a barn cat, a seasonal crew and eventually a combine thresher. They keep digging while the app is closed, for up to eight hours, and they never ask for a break. COLLECT ELEVEN NEEDLES From the entirely unremarkable Sewing Needle to the Golden Needle, the Obsidian Needle and the one they told you about. Six rarity tiers. Better luck pulls better needles. BALE OUT Clear eight haystacks and you can burn the whole barn down for a permanent hay multiplier. You keep the collection. You lose everything else. It is worth it. ONE THUMB, NO PRESSURE No timers demanding you come back. No lives. No punishment for putting it down for a week — the crew will have been busy. Idle Haystack is free to play and supported by optional ads. Watching one is always your choice: nothing in the game is gated behind an advert.

Screenshots

MurMur4 screens
Idle Haystack4 screens

Verdict

The call

The clearest difference is in-app purchases: Idle Haystack at none against MurMur's 5. MurMur's advantage is ads (none vs shown). On price, device support and iOS requirement there is nothing between them.

Scored on Price · Rating · Positive reviews · Number of ratings · Update frequency · Ads · In-app purchases · Monetization · Best chart rank · Devices · Requires iOS

CostPrice · In-app purchases · Ads · Monetization

Both are free to download. MurMur sells 5 one-off in-app purchases. Idle Haystack asks for nothing beyond the download.

Scorecard2 real differences · 4 level
MurMur versus Idle Haystack: the parameters behind the verdict, then further details
ParameterMurMurIdle Haystack
PriceFreeFree
Update frequencyEvery 2 weeks—
AdsNo — betterYes
In-app purchasesYesNo — better
DevicesiPhone, iPodiPhone, iPod
Requires iOS15.015.0
Further details — not scored
Size36 MB117 MB
Age rating4+4+
DeveloperBurhan KarakurtZIGL Ltd

In-app purchases

5 purchases

MurMur

One-time5
  • Shoal Swarm$1.99
  • Deep Sea Pack$2.99
  • Ember Night Pack$2.99
Show 2 more
  • Pulse Pack$2.99
  • Founder Pack$4.99
None

Idle Haystack

No in-app purchases

Questions

Is MurMur free?
MurMur is free to download, with in-app purchases available.
Is Idle Haystack free?
Idle Haystack is free to download, with no in-app purchases.
Do MurMur or Idle Haystack have ads?
Idle Haystack shows ads; MurMur does not.

Other comparisons