Leave a Review Magic Piano
🤢
So i got this app thinking it’d be a cool casual game to pass the time but immediately after I got my first song I was hit by a paywall and an abysmally large quantity of ads. Every time I started and finished a song I would have to watch an ad, a song that was previously free was now $7.99/month to access it otherwise I would have to pay in game currency (which they are stingy handing out). So unless you’re willing to frequently spend money on this app or willing to sit through 8+ ads every minute (seriously, not kidding they give a LOT of ads) then I suggest not to install this app ever, unless you’re doing it just to leave a bad review.
0/10 would burn down your studiosShow lessB R U H W H A T
Developer Response
Hey, We are here to assist with anything you experience while using Smule! You can contact our Support team so we can help you sort this out and go back to creating amazing performances! You can reach us here: https://smule.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/requests/new We are always here for our users!Great game but...
I have just proceded to watch 5 ads in hope to get smoola for a new song but in the end I wasn’t rewarded a single smoola, is this a glitch?
I love this game but this just makes it incredibly difficult and not fun to playWhy smoola why?
Nice, but there’s a few complaints I have to state
Overall this is a really enjoyable, fun game to play, and it’s highly addictive in my opinion but a few minutes ago an ad popped up after I’d finished playing my song on the piano and it had a curse word on the ad! I don’t feel it is appropriate to be allowing swear words or inappropriate content into a children’s game and it would be appreciated it this could be put into consideration! My second complaint is that there is way to many ads!! If there was fewer adds I think this app would get more good reviews and downloads!! 😊, the last thing I would like to address is that this app is meant for children if I’m not mistaken and there are songs published with swear words in the title.. kids will see this and think it’s ok, because they saw it on “magic piano” content moderators should be viewing songs published at all times and shouldn’t be allowing this onto a kids platform. Hopefully some of the things can be changed so magic piano can be a fun enjoyable environment for everyone!Show less44444445363737383838
5 stars
It’s a amazing game it never legs for me and that sound quality is amazing. The songs are great and I love the different piano sounds you can get. 100% would recommend.cameron the good man
I have a problem...
This is a good game, but there are lots of little things that I don’t like about it. Firstly, the coins that you need to use to buy other songs take ages to collect. Secondly, there are quite a few adverts which ruins the relaxing feel and thirdly, almost every time I download it I can only play it for a few minutes and then something goes wrong! For example, the last time I got it, it worked at first but then it kept on staying on the starting screen and not loading, and I’ve downloaded it now and, again, it worked at first but when I tried going on it again, it was frozen on where it was the moment I went off it, it was even stuck on the same lighting, and I just made my phone brighter!
So if you read this, could you please try to fix these things, I would really appreciate it.Show lessSam Stainton
It’s ok
It’s ok like it’s fun but some parts aren’t that greatjnshfirjdnfheiejfhh
Fun but musically inaccurate
I’ve been playing this game since it came out, and while I love the selection of music and playing the music, I find the games own sense of rhythm very frustrating.
Rather than approaching the line at a proper tempo, the notes go by your own sense of rhythm, and completely ignore rests in the music. A song often only sounds “right” when there is a constant string of notes coming. Any chords with gaps in between approach immediately after another and sound weird.
This makes it incredibly difficult to play - and is hilarious since they already realised this was an issue when they had to create a proper rhythm system in the jam feature so it matches singers! Which would be fun to use if it weren’t so frustratingly precise. It goes against everything I was trained for within the app.
Why not combine the best of both, have a consistent rhythm but the feature of tapping anywhere on screen?
Overall I enjoy the app, but as a person who enjoys music it is frustrating to listen to, and the game rewards you for playing a song wrong.Show lessEmemchan30
Loveable, life-long game! HERES SOME RECOMMENDATIONS
I’ve played this game since I was 11 years old and i’m almost 18 now. Let me just say, this app has improved insanely since the beginning and I’m super proud of the developers for opening the Composer ability. This has opened so many possibilities when it comes to music, I myself have purchased the pass to have full access to the library. It is a little pricey at $7.99 a week, but if your very deep into it then it shouldn’t be too much of a deal. I feel that long term users should get a discount if that was possible. Anyways, if the developers are still checking reviews and trying to improve their app, I feel like a perfect idea for improvement would be the ability to ORGANIZE your songs. Maybe you have a lot of classical songs and you would like them to be in a group. This is a KEY feature that would make navigating the app much more useful. Secondly, I would also recommend a feature that allows you to delete songs you didn’t enjoy playing, off of your songbook. Everyone has played a song they didn’t quite enjoy, but it stays on your songbook as long as you’ve played it. These two features would make the $7.99 a week pass much more worth it in my opinion. That’s all. Thank you guys!Show lessfattestbitchontheblock
its fun but not...
ive had the game for about 7 or 8 years and have had a lot of fun with it. but its just kinda lost its spark. i mean ads are ducked up you HAVE to dupe a song if u want it and it hasn't been updated in i think 4 or 5 years. Now do note the last time i wrote a review they fixed ( for about 2 months anyways) one of the major problems i rambled about in that review. buuuuut here i am... again
1) you can’t get any in game currency unless you buy it. end of story. you can waste your time watching ads but it will give you nothing this means the only my way to get a song and stay interested is to dupe it. which is technically stealing
2) all songs are duped. on my pricing i’ve got almost 130 songs. i only made about 4 of them. but you have to do this to be able to use the app. ( for those who don’t know his to avoid ads just look up free song magic piano on yt)
overall id say that ads need to not be the main way to get in game currency. there is a daily competition where you can get double points for about 24 hours. your score should give you points. whenever you play a song could give you points. they just need to revamp it or its gonna die. i know technically it already is but i see a few pol here like me who dont want to get rid of it but at some point or another will when problems keep arising. smule if you are reading this stop focusing on sing and pay a little attention to us pleaseShow lessbubblez110123
Used to be better
The Magic Piano used to be the game of all games. It was a nice challenge between friends and family, and it was fun. Now however, they have switched to a money making approach rather than keeping the app engaging. After each song you finish, you get an ad. After every action you take, you get an ad. You don’t earn many smoola and you level up very veeery slowly. Furthermore, the only way to get any free smoola doesn’t even work! How come does Smule thrown so many ads in my face and when I want to watch an ad for free smoola, it always says there are no ads currently available? Also, the “surveys and miscellaneous” smoola earning section does not work. I have tried many times and haven’t gotten any smoola. Finally, a lot of the songs I got a long time ago require me to watch an ad before playing them, and then another ad after. And some songs I bought don’t even work anymore with the error that they can’t download.
All in all, it’s an amazing app. I love it and I have been using it for a looong time but it has changed for the worse.Show lessGhostAnimoji
