Cartera T Reviews: Is It Legit?

Cartera T-mobilitat
Cartera T-mobilitat
Autoritat del Transport Metropolità de Barcelona

Customer Experience

Positive experience1.6% of reviews
Neutral0.0% of reviews
Negative experience98.4% of reviews

~ Based on 64 written reviews from the US App Store.

What users say about Cartera T

Is Cartera T Safe?

Cartera T-mobilitat does not appear safe based on available data. AppsHunter Safety Score for Cartera T is 36/100.

This assessment is based on 48 user ratings, with an App Store average of 1.1/5.

Safety Analysis

2.2% of ratings point to a safe experience
0.0% of ratings suggest some concerns
97.8% of ratings point to a risky experience

~ Based on 46 App Store ratings for Cartera T.

Is Cartera T Legit?

Cartera T-mobilitat appears legitimate, with a few gaps. AppsHunter Legitimacy Score for Cartera T is 73/100.

Based on 73 of 100 points across 7 verification signals from App Store and developer data.

Top reviews

Simpleton

The spanish are idiots, and the Catalan are 2x as dumb. What ever team programmed this should be beat with their stupid stale ham legs.

If you’re in the UK, don’t waste your time

I’m sure the app works fine for locals, but UK tourists should give this a miss.

The app doesn’t use the iOS travel card standard (as is Paris). Instead, a custom NFC permission is required. This is only available to EU users as it’s mandated by law.

UK users cannot grant the app the required permissions for ticket validation, and so any tickets you add to the digital wallet are useless.

It may be possible to work around this by changing you’re App Store region to an EU country, but this has adverse consequences (e.g it requires the cancellation of Apple One subscriptions), so I wasn’t willing to try it.

If you’re from the UK, buy a cardboard ticket from the vending machine and save yourself time and money.
Show more

Apple devices registered outside of Spain are NOT supported!!!!

Beware!!! Apple devices are not supported. You can buy a ticket but NOT use your device to validate the ticket at the metro gates!!!!!! DO NOT USE!

Poorest experience, they just need to invest in getting on the Apple train.

Absolutely horrible experience with the app, clunky and difficult to use. ATM just needs to invest the time and money to get this right by integrating into Apple transit. I get stuck behind so many people because their app won’t work. Stop cutting corners and give us a solution that actually works and saves riders time
Show more

Excuses

I see developer excuses replying to every review about technical limitations. I’d invite you to visit Paris or Tokyo. There’s simply no excuse for not offering a modern mobile pass that actually works.

Molt mala experiència d’us, torno a la targeta física

Pèssima implementació, al meu entendre no hauria de fer falta aquesta aplicació. La cartera d’Apple es pot obrir prement dues vegades el botó d’encesa. Encara que he provat de posar una drecera al botó d’acció, el fet d’estar al costat esquerre, almenys per mi es incòmode. He tornat al suport físic.
Show more

Don’t buy if you are from the US

Despite my entering my US address, the app waited until after charging to announce that it didn’t work with US phones. At this point, I want to move my purchase to my paper card and not convert my Apple ID to Europe (possibly messing up other settings).

Pésimo servicio

Solo se puede usar la app con la configuración del móvil en “región España”. Vivo aquí pero tengo cuentas y gestiones de Estados Unidos, no puedo cambiar toda la configuración de mi móvil para esta simple aplicación. Además que los fondos de la app no son transferibles a una tarjeta física. Ahora tengo dos opciones: cambiar toda la configuración del móvil (afecta las apps, la billetera virtual, subscripciones etc) o volver a pagar la tarifa completa por la tarjeta que compré. Ridículo. Habiliten para todas las regiones y nadie tendría este problema!!!
Show more

Simply does not work

This app just doesn’t work with a modern iPhone. How an app this bad is allowed to be released is beyond me. Essentially you need NFC to be able to use the app to travel. But…. There is no way to switch NFC on for the app (iOS standard is NFC on always) and the apple wallet always overrides this app so your bank card is always triggered.
Show more

Not working for phones sets to US region!

Get a physical card, this will not work..

Doesn’t work for non Spanish Apple accounts

It allows you to buy a ticket but when you try to use it gives a misleading error saying NFC isn’t working. Looking online it seems like your Apple account needs to have Spanish address.

Lacks integration with other transportation apps in BCN

Does not work if you have both the TMBApp and FGC App installed together in your phone. Useless

WARNING

Do not use this app. Once you purchase a pass, it will never let you use it displaying an NFC error. Nonexistent customer service. You will never see your money again. I wonder how this scam is even legal. Such an embarrassment for otherwise excellent Barcelona public transport.

Doesn’t work from US App Store

You can download the app from the US store. But when you launch the app it freezes at the start up screen. Nothing else happens.

I understand that Apple restricts NFC access for transit apps to EU regions. However, it might be worth reconsidering publishing the app on the US App Store if it is not usable by travelers from outside the EU.

Having the app available globally creates confusion for international visitors who download it expecting it to work, only to find it freezes or fails to function. This leads to frustration and negative reviews, which I’m sure is not your intention.

Perhaps adding a clear note in the App Store description explaining that “This app only works for iPhones set to an EU region due to Apple NFC restrictions” or restricting availability to EU countries would help set proper expectations.
Show more

Doesn’t work

This app shouldn’t even be available on the US App Store, since it doesn’t work with US devices

EU only

Can’t be used unless you’re an EU resident or you “change your Apple ID to an EU location” which is absurd because all your subscriptions and Apple One etc are linked to where you live.

No se activa el NFC

No, no aparece la opción de activar el NFC (or contactless) en la configuración. Tengo una tarjeta sin usar estancada ahí porque la aplicación no sirve. Devuélvanme mi dinero.

Does not work with iPhone new models.

Waste of time and money

Doesn’t work

Takes your money but NFC doesn’t work. FIRE THE DEVELOPERS

Estafa.

Te dejan hacer el billete pero no funciona y si les pides el dinero atrás te dicen que no pueden dártelo. Yo he gastado 30€ por culpa de ellos.