Better But Still Needs Work
Vaporware
I’m happy to report I’ve been able to add stars to my review. The new version of Notebooks, after some growing pains, supports the features I had when o bought my smart pen 2 years ago. Sync works, transcription is good even for my chicken scratch, and I’m beginning to see value again in my investment in the Moleskine Smart system.
Update OCT 22 2025
I can’t express my disappointment enough. There was a silent decision to disable sync in Jan 2025 while working on a new improved version. So far I’ve been given 4 release dates. June of 25, Sept of 25, Oct of 25, and now in a response to someone else’s comments, Nov of 25. 10 months without sync to their server, and no end in site. I purchased this and one of the key features was sync between my iPhone and iPad. I paid a premium price for what I assumed was a premium device and service. What a let down.
UPDATE July 3 2025
I’ve had to remove some stars. Several months ago, my sync stoped working. I was told at the time that they were working on a new version, and turned off the sync servers to get ready for the new product, and it would be ready “hopefully by June”
I’m disappointed that users weren’t notified that sync would be disabled for an extended time, and that there is no updated timeline for the new version. I understand there are often delays in software development, but the overall lack of communication leaves a lot to be desired. Especially when cross device sync was a key feature Moleskine announced for this product.
**original review**
I purchased a competitor’s product last summer. I had an issue and contacted support, and no response to multiple inquiries over a couple of weeks time.
I decided to purchase the Moleskine Smart system as a smart notebook is helpful in my work, and it lives up to its promise. I did have a minor issue which I’ve reported to their support, and got a timely and helpful response. I wish I bought this system in the first place.
Moleskin pen no longer supported
Mandatory purchase of new pen
New Moleskine Notebooks app is unusable
The new version keeps telling me I have multiple versions of my notebooks and asks me which one I want to keep. For example I have one notebook labeled 2026, but a message pops up whenever I use the pen, i.e. write a word—pop up, do I want to make this my default notebook and archive the others?—write a second word—pop up, do I want to make this my default notebook and archive the others?—write a third word, same pop up. Seriously annoying.
The new app doesn’t completely update. Many pages are blank or contain only a small portion of the content that is in the paper notebook. There doesn’t seem to be any way to go back to the old app and retrieve everything that the pen wrote.
Very disappointed. Would rate it a zero if I could.
Old Moleskine app was better
Pretty Bad
New update is horrendous
It is incredibly slow, choppy, nothing is loading.
It will not load any of the pages. Absolutely useless now.
Total downgrade
Getting There
I need to pay to view the calendar? Very disappointed
That is very disappointing for a client who has never betrayed you over the years. I understand there are management costs but I paid a lot for the set and as longstanding client that trusted this feature even if there were a thousands much better out there, now having to pay to see my calendar feels really like a betrayal!!
Achtung Nutzer des SmartPen Triangular: Betrugsalarm!!
Response from developer
Dear Aerni68, thank you for your feedback. The Smart Pen you are using is one of our earliest models and was released many years ago. It was already replaced by newer generations, including the current F130 Smart Pen, which has been available for approximately four years. Unfortunately, due to the evolution of mobile devices, operating systems, and Bluetooth technology, the original triangular Smart Pen is no longer fully compatible with modern platforms. This is not due to a defect in the pen itself, but rather to the significant technological changes that have occurred over the years. We understand your disappointment and appreciate your understanding. Please reach us out to find a solution team@moleskineeveryday.com Thanks.
Anciens stylos non compatibles - vente forcée des produits plus récents
Response from developer
Dear Luttx, thank you for your feedback. The Smart Pen you are using is one of our earliest models and was released many years ago. It was already replaced by newer generations, including the current F130 Smart Pen, which has been available for approximately four years. Unfortunately, due to the evolution of mobile devices, operating systems, and Bluetooth technology, the original triangular Smart Pen is no longer fully compatible with modern platforms. This is not due to a defect in the pen itself, but rather to the significant technological changes that have occurred over the years. We understand your disappointment and appreciate your understanding. Please reach us out to find a solution team@moleskineeveryday.com Thanks.
Holding users hostage
Smart Pen Doesn’t Work
No longer use my system. There should have been a notification that said to
not update the app or your older pen won’t work. This feels like a scam to get me to pay for a new pen.
YOU CANNOT ACCESS YOUR NOTEBOOKS IF YOU DON’T USE THEIR CLOUD SERVICES
This new 3.0 major update forces you to upload all of your old notes to the cloud. After updating the app, they give you an option to export your old notebooks to an offline format (probably pdf) but that option only comes up once. If you skip that export option (which I did to better understand my options later in the legacy notebook migration flow), you’re basically screwed; you are forced to upload all your content to their cloud. If you don’t upload your content to their cloud, they lock you out of YOUR notebooks.
IF YOU DON’T USE THEIR CLOUD SERVICE, YOU CANNOT ACCESS YOUR NOTEBOOKS.
In summary:
- It costs over $200 USD for their criminally mediocre “smart” pen
- NO OFFLINE OPTION: In order to use Moleskin’s “smart” notebook system, you are forced to upload your content to their cloud services.
- This is an egregious, user-hostile change to this moleskin “smart” ecosystem.
I’ll admit the physical Moleskin notebooks are wonderful. Great products. But the “smart”/digital side of the ecosystem is a scam.
We, the users are now the product. They’re going to milk us for our data and we’ll inevitably find out about a massive data breach at some point.
Do yourself a favor and avoid Moleskin’s “smart” products. I feel anything but smart for getting so invested in their garbage.
Nice idea but unreliable
Bravo
Response from developer
Dear 락평, thank you for your feedback. Feedback like yours is very important to us, as it helps us continue improving the app and delivering the best possible experience. We’re glad to hear that you’re enjoying the app and making the most of its features. Thanks.
Catastrophique
Response from developer
Dear Gonchi4, thank you for your feedback, and we’re sorry to hear about your experience. We’d really like to help you resolve this please contact us directly through the app so we can support you more effectively. We’re working hard to improve the app experience redesigning those actions that may be confusing and fixing the bugs reported. We are releasing updates weekly. Thank you again for your feedback.
