Precious Coin Tester User Reviews

What users say

Top reviews

Saving money

Saved me so many times

Thankful!!

Finally an app that isn’t trying to bleed you for money! I appreciate this company for making this app easy to use and free of charge!

THANK YOU!!!

Response from developer

Thanks for your review!

Clunky

This app does what it’s supposed to but using it needs improvement. The search feature is terrible. I ran a search for “0.25 eagle” and it returned zero results. Then tried again and it came back with only two results, both were for half ounce coins. Trying to find the most basic coins is a chore so after over a year of paying for this app, I’m leaving and will verify my gold and silver purchases through alternative means.
Show more

Response from developer

Hello, We are sorry to hear that. Would you like to try "Gold eagle" directly as keyword? The app has a huge database and the search sometimes cannot find the optimum results. Please feel free to reach out to us by email, we are happy to help on any concerns on the app. We will also work on reducing the difficulty in the coin search. Best regards, Precious Coin Tester team

Money saver

Without this tool, I would have accepted over $1,000 in bogus Morgans and Silver Ridge coins.
More than pays for itself on a daily basis.

Response from developer

Thanks a lot for your review! We are very happy that the app has helped, it's our objective :)

Network Error

I’ve tried using the app multiple times with different coins and always got a “network error” message.

Accurate but hard to use User interface

The app seems to be working very accurately, however, the user interface is very finicky and could use some very basic upgrades, such as being able to save the most used coins. That way you don’t have to look for them every time, and improving the search function as it could be very difficult to find some coins
Show more

Response from developer

Thanks a lot for your review! We understand your concerns. The search ability should have already been improved in 2.1.0. If you find any concrete examples of search issues, please drop us a mail at preciouscointester@gmail.com. We are more than happy to know them! We will also continue on improving other aspects to make the app easier to use :)

Not useful

Most the various coins are locked until you pay. I tried to test a few coins to try this app out and it doesn’t work. Clicked “check” then clinged my coin and nothing, tried again and again, doesn’t work. No waves no response nothing. My coins gonna get scratched up plus they keep falling onto the floor. Time for a new tester.
Show more

New Point System is not good

What is the new point system? Why do I need points if I’m already a subscriber?

1 star for unecessary popups and no explanation

Zzz

Works pretty well. Sometimes see “network error” when trying to use, but usually it works.

Response from developer

Hello, we are sorry for what you have experienced. Would you please drop us a mail at preciouscointester@gmail.com with more details, so we can investigate and solve the issue?

Better than nothing

Gave me a 3/3 rating for a glass jar while testing for ASEs. Just another data point, don’t bet the house on just this app. Update - the right coin was selected, the point is you can fool the app with false positives.

Response from developer

Hello, the correct coin needs to be selected before performing the test in order to have a meaningful result. (Otherwise, you can use a musical instrument to get any result you want :D) You can find some best practices here: https://preciouscointester.com/en/best_practices.html

Disappointed

I bought to test U.S. 90% gold and silver coins. There are only 2 coins that be tested for free. A one silver dollar and a one ounce twenty dollar. No other denominations available without a subscription. Also, you can’t use the special parameters section without a description.

After paying $30 for the device, I expected more options.
Show more

Response from developer

Hello, we don't sell any device in our company. Maybe you mean the "pocket pinger". It belongs to a different company. The subscription fee helps us to maintain the app and improve it continuously. We are very sorry for your misunderstanding. If you could point out which pieces of information have misled you, it will be very helpful for us, and will the make it clearer.

Subscription plan likely limiting sales revenue

Econ 101: Price up = demand down

Subscriptions are generally reviled, so, perhaps you could increase your revenue by figuring a way to segment your prospective customer base.

Maybe a one-time fee for just the *custom* tester (i.e., no access to the coin library).
Or maybe:
One-time fee—say, $9.99—for access to the current database but some additional fee for the annual update (heck, and even a $1.99 annual “maintenance fee” for a “Basic” plan).

For example, I don’t buy rounds; I buy old silver. I’d pay 10 bucks for the current library, but I have no need for annual updates. Let those who need them have the option to buy them.

More money is made via a “Volume, volume, volume!” strategy than by exclusionary pricing. How many new “casual users” could you entice with a lower-priced “Basic” plan?
Show more

Response from developer

Hello, Thanks for your suggestions! Our updates are not limited to adding new coins, it also improves precision of existing ones, and fix false positive or false negative results if we found any. These updates help to better protect our users against fake coins. We also need to keep comply with the latest requirements from AppStore, which ensure the sustainability of the service. The subscription model fits the type of our expense for the moment. We will think about your suggestions and it may be more suitable later in the future. Thanks again for your suggestion and understanding!

Locked behind a paywall subscription

The app used to be great, everything was free to test. Now you need to pay 3$ a month. Ridiculous

Server error coinstantly.

Paid for a subscription and server always down. A refund would be nice!

Helpfull

Very helpfull if you have hearing loss or tone loss

Silver Libertad and Gold Maple Leaf

I have tested on these two 1 oz silver and gold coins. Very easy to find the coins in the search and I had ping tested everyone to my satisfaction.

Says everything is good.

Didn't fail any of my coins even when I pinged the wrong ones on purpose. Passed an ASE as a gold double eagle a couple times in a row 3/3.

Subscriptions subscriptions subscriptions

This subscription model is tired lame and needs to be put out of it’s misery. I’m not paying $36 a year for an app I might use 2 times a month. My dealer has a tester that I can use for free. If you want my money then either charge $.50 a month or 4.99 for a years worth of updates. Until the I’ll find another to check ALL of my coins for free.
Show more

What a joke! NOT very accurate!

This app is a joke for real. First of all, misleading to have access the manual feature so you are force to subscribe. After subscription, only then tells you that the manual is not 3/3 accurate. Also, the results are varies with the same coins. 2023 Britannia silver 1 oz is not even in the coin list. It so hard pick the region as it’s very sensitive when you’re rolling the region choices. Don’t waste your money to subscribe, its a useless tool.
Show more

Excellent App

Free version was more than enough for me. Allows you to select Buffalo Rounds. Was still able to test my Eagles with this too, as the size is all that matters. Tested bars and junk I have to see how legitimate the rounds tester is. Spot on every time. Can’t see how anyone could complain. Free version is good enough for me.
Show more