Stew Leonard's Loyalty App User Reviews

Customer Experience

Positive experience7.1% of reviews
Neutral8.1% of reviews
Negative experience84.8% of reviews

~ Based on 99 written reviews from the US App Store.

What users say

Is Stew Leonard's Loyalty App Safe?

Stew Leonard's Loyalty App has mixed safety signals based on user ratings. AppsHunter Safety Score for Stew Leonard's Loyalty App is 58/100.

This assessment is based on 463 user ratings, with an App Store average of 2.9/5.

Safety Analysis

42.8% of ratings point to a safe experience
8.8% of ratings suggest some concerns
48.4% of ratings point to a risky experience

~ Based on 432 App Store ratings for Stew Leonard's Loyalty App.

Is Stew Leonard's Loyalty App Legit?

Stew Leonard's Loyalty App appears legitimate, with a few gaps. AppsHunter Legitimacy Score for Stew Leonard's Loyalty App is 78/100.

Based on 78 of 100 points across 7 verification signals from App Store and developer data.

Top reviews

The app never works

Always getting incore t user name and password. Never works.. completely sucks. I even stopped going to stew Leonard’s and shop some else now.

Review

Don’t shop as much at Stews .Have an old phone and can’t get the app. I was told at their store to buy a more updated phone .Wow what nerve!

Unfair points drop

I’ve always admired the rock at your front door: 'The Customer is Always Right.' As a regular shopper spending hundreds of dollars here, the new 6-month points expiration feels like it goes against that spirit. We earn these rewards with our loyalty, and they should be ours to keep until we choose to use them. In the spirit of Rule #1, please reconsider this policy and continue to honor your customers by letting our points stay put.
Show more

New App

I found the same thing with my already existing app. Unlike the above costumer if they do not find a way to redeem points will have to consider not shopping here despite being a loyal customer for years!

I love Stew Leonard's

I love coming to this store ! We go to the one in Newington CT. The employees are very friendly and knowledgeable! The food is amazing ❤️The animatronics makes the store have fun vibe. Plus they always give out free samples ! The phone app I love . It's very easy to use

Review

Don’t shop as much at Stews .Have an old phone and can’t get the app. I was told at their store to buy a more updated phone .Wow what nerve!

Always booted and won’t let me reset my pw

Always booted and won’t let me reset my pw

Needs some logical updates

Few things that would help:
1.Phone number verification
2.Email verification
3.Sign in using phone number (sends a code)
4. “Press yes to confirm redemption”
5. Allow for points to be returned during app error
6. Coupons should work if I add them at checkout.
7. Password reset should last longer then a day
8. Why am I allowed to use a few coupons some time but only one for other times
9. Might be a good idea to create a physical card for those who don’t have a smartphone
Once you start addressing some of those issues, you’ll start seeing more positive customers.
Show more

Can’t even make an account

Tried for over a week to make an account and it keeps saying to try back again later and never works. Went into the store and they didn’t have any ability to make an account for me. Manager even said I’m not the first person to tell him this.

Love Stews

I have been using the app since it came and have never had an issue with it. I love that it’s now a cumulative total for free ice cream. And my son gets excited when I randomly say let’s go get ice cream from Stews!

Update This!!

I can’t the open the app, because my phone won’t take the update necessary. I guess I’ll get a new phone so I can shop at Stew Leonard’s. Thanks for nothing. Can you say Uncle Giuseppe’s?

Does not work

I cannot log in. Tried everything. Deleted the app, changed the password. Contacted support. No resolution. So frustrating!

Update This!!

I can’t the app open because my phone won’t take the update necessary. I guess I’ll get a new phone so I can save at Stew Leonard’s. Thanks for nothing

App review

Every time I click onto the icon, I have to update the app. I don’t think that’s right.

Web site—

Terrible update, all info and points lost not allowed to reset password, have to love the update.

Always need to log in

This app is always needing updates. Annoying that you have to sign in due to being booted out.

App is terrible

The app booted me off and won’t let me log back into it anymore no matter what I do and they won’t allow you to get the free ice cream without the app. Total joke!

Horrible experience

When app last updated on March 4/5 2025 all of my points disappeared. Continued purchases have not accumulated points. Had almost 3,000 points. Have spoken with Stews several times at service desk and Farmingdale store manager. No call backs, no resolution, no points replaced!

App doesn’t work

my apps stopped working. I sent an email to corporate head they sent me for the link and I get the same stupid message. Try again in a few minutes this has been I went to the store I I emailed the Tech-Support all negative results so now I have 500 points I can’t use them. I can’t get any free ice cream useless garbage. I can’t believe a company’s biggest can’t resolve this
Show more

Stew Leonard’s

Great Supermarket one of a kind.Great food and place.I always walk out of here with a smile and ice cream lol!!!!!