Canto
doesnt work
Response from developer
Hi Harriet, sorry you are having issues. Please check that Artie has microphone permission enabled, close any other apps using the microphone and try removing your phone case. You can also connect by MIDI or Bluetooth MIDI for more accurate note detection. We hear you on wanting to get to the song faster too. Please email us at info@artmaster.com with your account email, device details and User ID, which you can find at the bottom of Artie settings, and weâll help check whatâs going wrong.
Attention avant de souscrire abonnement
Response from developer
Bonjour Nicolas, dĂ©solĂ©s que lâexpĂ©rience ait Ă©tĂ© aussi frustrante. Les abonnements et les tentatives de paiement sont gĂ©rĂ©s par Apple via lâApp Store, pas directement par Artie. Supprimer votre compte Artie ne permet pas dâannuler un abonnement App Store ni dâarrĂȘter le processus de paiement dâApple. Veuillez vĂ©rifier vos abonnements dans lâApp Store et annuler Artie Ă cet endroit sâil est toujours actif. Si vous voyez encore des tentatives de paiement aprĂšs cela, contactez directement lâassistance Apple, ou Ă©crivez-nous Ă info@artmaster.com et nous vous aiderons Ă vĂ©rifier ce quâil se passe de notre cĂŽtĂ©.
My review
Any changes id suggest?
I know itâs a new app but the increase of more songs would be great!! Also when teaching, it be nice to have some type of standard to move on to the next task. Not to limit it but to make sure the AI knows you can play well enough before moving on.
Like a friendly push.
Great app!!
Response from developer
Thanks Kickerzzz! Really glad youâre enjoying Artie. More songs are definitely coming. Weâre also working on a big update to the way Learn with Artie works, with more adaptive learning that should better understand when youâre ready to move on, and when you need that extra friendly push. Thanks for the thoughtful review đč
NĂŁo reconhece as notas do teclado
Response from developer
Sentimos que vocĂȘ esteja tendo esses problemas. Verifique se o microfone estĂĄ livre, feche outros apps que possam estar usando o microfone e tente remover a capa do celular. VocĂȘ tambĂ©m pode conectar por MIDI ou Bluetooth MIDI para uma detecção mais precisa. Se ele ainda nĂŁo reconhecer corretamente as teclas brancas, escreva para info@artmaster.com e nĂłs vamos ajudar.
Review
1. low choice of songs/no import option
2. In my opinion bad sound recognition
3. Overly repetitive monologues of the ai
3 stars is my conclusion because im rather an intermediate player and i think this app is rather build for beginners who learn simple chords and finger positions than arpeggios and dynamic play.
Response from developer
Hi, thanks for the thoughtful feedback. Artie is especially useful for beginners, but we do want it to feel valuable for more intermediate players too. You can now import your own MIDI and MusicXML files, and weâre continuing to improve note recognition, the AI guidance and the song library. We really appreciate the specific points. They help us see where Artie needs to get better.
Went through my bank account straightaway
Response from developer
Hi, sorry this caused concern. Artie canât charge you just for downloading the app. Any $0 notification would usually be an App Store payment check or authorisation, not a charge from us. A trial or subscription can only start through Appleâs App Store flow, where the terms are shown before you confirm. Weâre sorry this felt unclear, and weâll keep working to make the subscription flow as transparent as possible.
Premium
Response from developer
Hi, weâre sorry those songs were removed. Song availability can change over time, especially with popular music, and we know thatâs frustrating when youâve been practising songs you enjoy. Weâre continuing to add more music, and you can now import your own MIDI files too, so you have more flexibility beyond the built-in library.
Great!!
Top mais !
Peut ĂȘtre un jour, dans une prochaine mise Ă jour ?
Response from developer
Merci ! Le français arrivera dans une future mise Ă jour. Ravi de voir que vous vous intĂ©ressez Ă Artie đč
Donât even do the trial, or you will pay $150
Gut zum Auswendiglernen
Die App macht SpaĂ, eröffnet einen besonderen Fokus auf die Musik und ist gerade fĂŒrs Auswendiglernen eine echte Bereicherung. Schön wĂ€re noch, die Geschwindigkeit stufenlos statt in 25er-Schritten anpassen zu können.
Ăber Liszts âLiebestraumâ und weitere anspruchsvollere Chopin-StĂŒcke wĂŒrde ich mich sehr freuen. Auch fĂŒr fortgeschrittene Klavierspieler auf jeden Fall einen Blick wert!
Response from developer
Vielen Dank fĂŒr diese ausfĂŒhrliche Bewertung. Es freut uns sehr, dass dir die FingersĂ€tze und das Auswendiglernen mit Artie so gut helfen. Deine Hinweise zu Triller-FingersĂ€tzen und einer feineren Tempo-Einstellung sind sehr hilfreich, und wir geben sie an das Team weiter. Liebestraum und weitere anspruchsvollere Chopin-StĂŒcke nehmen wir auch gern in unsere Wunschliste auf đč
Tutorials sind okay aberâŠ
Response from developer
Hallo, danke, dass du das gemeldet hast. Der KI-Assistent sollte deine Frage nicht einfach nur wiederholen, da funktioniert also offensichtlich etwas nicht richtig. Bitte aktualisiere Artie auf die neueste Version. Falls das weiterhin passiert, kontaktiere uns unter info@artmaster.com, damit wir das untersuchen können.
Bien mais problĂšme de micro
Response from developer
Bonjour, dĂ©solĂ©s que vous soyez bloquĂ©e avec ce problĂšme. Il semble quâArtie nâait peut-ĂȘtre pas lâautorisation dâutiliser le micro dans les rĂ©glages de votre iPhone. Allez dans RĂ©glages de lâiPhone > ConfidentialitĂ© et sĂ©curitĂ© > Microphone et vĂ©rifiez quâArtie est bien activĂ©. Vous pouvez aussi essayer de fermer les autres apps qui utilisent le micro et de retirer la coque de votre tĂ©lĂ©phone. Si lâapp ne rĂ©agit toujours pas, Ă©crivez-nous Ă info@artmaster.com et nous vous aiderons.
top
Response from developer
Obrigado! Que bom saber que vocĂȘ estĂĄ gostando do Artie đč
Excepcional
Por favor vejam
Response from developer
OlĂĄ Breno, obrigado por dedicar um tempo para escrever isso. Suas sugestĂ”es sĂŁo muito Ășteis. VocĂȘ jĂĄ pode importar arquivos MusicXML, alĂ©m de MIDI, e o MusicXML pode incluir dedilhado. Mas concordamos que seria muito melhor poder editar as importaçÔes diretamente dentro do Artie, e Ă© algo em que estamos trabalhando. TambĂ©m vamos passar suas ideias sobre mais importaçÔes gratuitas e dificuldade ajustĂĄvel.
Minha avaliação
Response from developer
Obrigado, Valentina! Ficamos muito felizes que o Artie esteja ajudando vocĂȘ a aprender no seu prĂłprio ritmo đč
The Problem with Artie: A Gimmicky Shortcut to Nowhere
Zero Musical Literacy: It trains mechanical visual reaction time, not the ability to read standard notation, understand key signatures, or recognize harmonic patterns. Once you turn off the screen, you are left unable to sit down with a piece of sheet music.
Flawed Note Detection & Mechanics: Like many microphone-reliant apps, note recognition frequently hiccups on acoustic resonance or polyphonic textures. More critically, an app cannot assess hand weight, wrist relaxation, dynamic phrasing, or finger independence.
Shallow Musical Understanding: Artie treats music as pure muscle memory rather than an auditory language. You end up memorizing key locations for a specific track without understanding why the chord progression works.
Why flowkey Is a Significant Step Up
If you want an interactive app, flowkey is fundamentally designed around actual musicianship rather than arcade gaming:
Dual-View with Real Notation: flowkey displays synchronized professional sheet music alongside high-definition video of an instructorâs hands. You naturally learn to associate printed notation with physical keyboard geography.Â
Dedicated Practice Tools: The app excels in targeted practice workflowsâallowing you to loop isolated 2-bar phrases, slow down tempo without pitch distortion, isolate left/right hands, and use a responsive "Wait Mode" that holds until the correct voicing is played.Â
Expansive, High-Quality Repertoire: Rather than simplified snippets, flowkey offers complete, tiered arrangements across classical, pop, film, and jazz standards.
Why a Structured Course Like Piano with Jonny Is in a Different League
While flowkey teaches you how to execute specific pieces, Piano with Jonny (Jonny May) teaches you how to play the instrument:
Deep Harmonic Understanding: Jonny breaks down functional harmony, chord voicings (e.g., shell voicings, rootless 7ths, altered extensions), and groove foundations.
Improvisation and Freedom: Instead of turning you into a human music box that only plays pre-programmed scores note-for-note, courses like this teach you how to take a simple chord progression or lead sheet and craft your own fills, rhythm patterns, and variations on the fly.
Nuance, Touch, and Articulation: Real video masterclasses cover the subtleties of swing feel, syncopation, left-hand bass lines, and dynamic touch that no automated software algorithm can convey.
While apps like Artie offer the illusion of quick progress through gamification, flowkey actually teaches repertoire, and a comprehensive course like Piano with Jonny gives you the tools to become a fluent, self-sufficient pianist.
