Best Coleys Pizza alternatives: apps like Coleys Pizza

10+ similar apps compared and reviewed

4.7 avg rating
10 free apps
Updated November 2026

Whether you want more options like Coleys Pizza or a completely different take on the same concept, our curated list of 10+ similar apps has you covered. Updated for 2026 with the latest ratings and comparisons.

Top Alternatives to Coleys Pizza

Sedano's#1

Sedano's by Smrt Solutions, LLC

Sedano's Marketplaces
Editor's Choice
🍔 Food & Drink
4.9(542 ratings)
FreeAds
Sedano's screenshot 1
Sedano's screenshot 2
Sedano's screenshot 3

Easily shop for groceries with same-day delivery or in-store pickup. Browse weekly deals, view product details, and reorder past purchases quickly. Get your favorite items selected by trained personal shoppers.

3.8😞(183 ratings)
FreeAds
Flanigan's Seafood Bar & Grill screenshot 1
Flanigan's Seafood Bar & Grill screenshot 2
Flanigan's Seafood Bar & Grill screenshot 3
Flanigan's Seafood Bar & Grill screenshot 4

Easily order your favorite seafood dishes for pickup and earn rewards with every purchase. Stay updated on exclusive deals and promotions available only to app users.

What We Love

  • 😋 Delicious food quality
  • 👍 User-friendly app interface
  • 🌟 Great deals and specials
  • 💯 Consistent food quality
  • 🚀 Quick and easy ordering
  • 🎉 Celebratory app features

Room to Improve

  • 😠 Poor customer service
  • 📉 Declining food quality
  • ⏳ Long wait times
  • 📱 App bugs and crashes
  • 💸 Service fees on app orders
  • 👎 Complicated new rewards program
  • 🚫 Privacy concerns with data sharing
  • 🚗 Parking issues for takeout
Talkin Tacos#3

Talkin Tacos by Talkin Tacos LLC

Easy ordering & rewards
Worth Considering
🍔 Food & Drink
4.9😊(3.7K ratings)
Free
Talkin Tacos screenshot 1
Talkin Tacos screenshot 2
Talkin Tacos screenshot 3
Talkin Tacos screenshot 4
Talkin Tacos screenshot 5
Talkin Tacos screenshot 6

Easily order your favorite meals directly from the restaurant for the best prices. Earn rewards points for free food and enjoy convenient, real-time order tracking. Support a local business with every secure transaction.

What We Love

  • 👍 Excellent restaurant application
  • 👍 Amazing food quality
  • 👍 Friendly and service-oriented staff
  • 👍 Convenient online ordering and payment
  • 👍 Consistent taste and flavors
  • 👍 Halal options available
  • 👍 Great local food

Room to Improve

  • 🐛 Outdated app with missing features
  • 🐛 Long wait times for order pickup
  • 🐛 Issues with order accuracy and completeness

More apps like Coleys Pizza

4
Bolay Fresh Bold Kitchen
Bolay Fresh Bold Kitchen
Bolay Fresh Bold Kitchen
Order Ahead, Delivery, Offers
Free

Craft your perfect meal with a variety of healthy grains, greens, and proteins. Order ahead for convenient pickup or delivery, and earn rewards through the loyalty program.

Create custom bowlsOrder for pickupDelivery options
🍔 Food & Drink
(7.3K)
free
5
Cali Coffee
Cali Coffee
Cali Coffee
Pay. Earn Points. Use Rewards.
Free

This app allows users to pay for their orders using a digital card, earn loyalty points, and redeem rewards. Browse the menu, find nearby locations, and stay updated on specials and promotions.

Contactless payment via QR codeIntegrated loyalty programBrowse full menu
🍔 Food & Drink
(62)
free
6
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza
by Florida Coal Fired Pizza LLC
Free

Easily order your favorite coal-fired pizzas, wings, and more for pickup or delivery. Join the rewards program to earn points, access exclusive discounts, and get free food. Find nearby locations and browse the full menu.

Order ahead for pickup or deliveryEarn rewards points and discountsFind nearby locations
🍔 Food & Drink
(4.5K)
free
7
BurgerFi
BurgerFi
BurgerFi
Order ahead and get rewarded!
Free

Easily order your favorite burgers and sides for quick pick-up. Join the rewards program to earn points, get free fries upon registration, and receive special birthday treats and exclusive offers.

Order ahead for pick-upMobile payment with saved cardsDigital gift cards
🍔 Food & Drink
(9.2K)
free
8
Pollo Tropical
Pollo Tropical
Pollo Tropical
Order! Enjoy! Get Rewarded!
Free

Easily order your favorite Caribbean-inspired dishes for pickup or delivery. Join the loyalty program to earn points, receive exclusive offers, and get rewarded with free food. Discover new menu items and save your go-to orders for quick reordering.

Browse menuPlace pickup ordersPlace delivery orders
🍔 Food & Drink
(43K)
free with in-app purchases
9
Miller's Ale House Ordering
Miller's Ale House Ordering
Miller's Ale House Ordering
by Miller's Ale House, Inc.
Free

Easily order your favorite meals for pickup or delivery from a popular restaurant chain. Enjoy a wide selection of burgers, signature wings, and desserts. Save time and satisfy your cravings with convenient mobile ordering.

Mobile food orderingZing in Zing out pickupDelivery to select areas
🍔 Food & Drink
(12K)
free with in-app purchases
10
Bubbakoo's Burritos
Bubbakoo's Burritos
Bubbakoo's Burritos
Pickup. Delivery. Rewards
Free

Easily order and pay for your favorite burritos and more ahead of time for pickup or delivery. Access exclusive rewards, special offers, and insider news to enhance your dining experience.

Order aheadPay aheadPickup options
🍔 Food & Drink
(23K)
free