Comparison

Nuuly vs Madewell

Price, ratings, monetisation and update history for both apps, side by side — with what reviewers say about each.

Head to head
About

Nuuly

This subscription service lets you rent six clothing items monthly from a wide selection of brands and sizes. Keep items all month, with laundry and repairs included. You can also purchase items you love at a discount.

Highlights
  • Rent 6 items monthly
  • Wide range of brands and sizes (XS-5X)
  • Laundry and repairs included
  • Purchase favorites at a discount
  • Fast, free shipping and returns
  • Pause or cancel anytime
Features
Currently charting
Read full description

Nuuly is a subscription clothing rental service built to help you get creative with what you wear every day—not just on special occasions. Rent 6 items every month for $98 and choose from 100s of brands and 1000s of styles in sizes XS–5X, including petite, tall + maternity. How it works: * Pick any 6 items—four tops and the same dress in two sizes? Six pairs of jeans? One of everything? It's your call
 * Keep them all month. Don't worry about laundry or repairs—it's included in the plan
 * If you fall in love with something, buy it at a discount. Send back the rest + repeat
 Why you’ll love Nuuly: * Fast, free shipping + returns * No late fees or damage fees—ever * Pause or cancel anytime
 With the Nuuly app, you can: * Quickly save favorites in your Closet + sort them into Closet Lists * Add styles to your Nuuly quickly + seamlessly * Manage subscription, profile details + rental history with one tap * Purchase favorites: keep one, two or all of your items * Leave reviews for the Nuuly community * Get customizable iOS push notifications for Nuuly news

About

Madewell

Discover and shop the latest fashion, from denim to accessories. Track your loyalty benefits, view order history, and get inspired by curated editorials. Save favorites and enjoy a seamless checkout experience.

Highlights
  • Shop latest arrivals
  • Track Insider benefits
  • View order history
  • Save favorite styles
  • Read customer reviews
  • Discover editorials
Features
Read full description

Introducing the best way to experience the world of Madewell. Sign in and start exploring the latest denim and forever essentials, plus easily track your Insider benefits, order history and more. DISCOVER: Get inspired by our latest editorials that you can shop the looks from, learn about our exclusive collaborations and in-store events, plus read helpful customer reviews. SHOP: Explore what’s new (from just-in jeans to accessories that make the outfit) and speed through our seamless checkout. Just browsing? You can save your favorite styles to a list for later. ACCESS: Easily track your Madewell Insider status, benefits and invites to exclusive Insider-only events in the app. Sign into your account to earn points as you shop and unlock new rewards along the way.

Screenshots

Nuuly4 screens
Madewell4 screens

Verdict

The call

Nuuly and Madewell both sit at 4.9 stars, but that hides the real split: 67% of Nuuly's written reviews are positive against 11% of Madewell's. Nuuly also leads on ads (none vs shown) and chart position (#192 vs unranked). Madewell's advantage is monetization model (free with in-app purchases vs subscription) and iOS requirement (17.0 vs 26.0). On price, rating, ratings volume and update cadence there is nothing between them.

Scored on Price · Rating · Positive reviews · Number of ratings · Update frequency · Ads · In-app purchases · Monetization · Best chart rank · Devices · Requires iOS

CostPrice · In-app purchases · Ads · Monetization

Both are free to download. Neither carries in-app purchases, so what you see is what you pay.

ReceptionRating · Positive reviews · Number of ratings

Nuuly holds the better App Store score, 4.9 against 4.8. Both are backed by a comparable volume of ratings — 32K and 26K respectively. Written reviews point the same way: 67% of Nuuly's written reviews are positive against 11% of Madewell's.

UpkeepUpdate frequency

Nuuly ships an update every 9 days, Madewell fortnightly. Both last shipped on November 16, 2026.

Scorecard5 real differences · 6 level
Nuuly versus Madewell: the parameters behind the verdict, then further details
ParameterNuulyMadewell
PriceFreeFree
Rating4.9 (32K ratings) — better4.8 (26K ratings)
Positive reviews66.6% of reviews — better10.5% of reviews
Number of ratings32K — better26K
Update frequencyEvery 9 days — betterFortnightly
AdsNo — betterYes
In-app purchasesNoNo
MonetizationSubscriptionFree with in-app purchases — better
Best chart rank#192 — better—
DevicesiPhoneiPhone
Requires iOS26.017.0 — better
Further details — not scored
Size93 MB129 MB
Age rating4+4+
DeveloperNuulyJCrew Group INC

Customer experience

Nuuly

All ratings31,683 ratings
Positive98.4%
Neutral0.8%
Negative0.8%
Written reviews317 reviews
Positive66.6%
Neutral13.2%
Negative20.2%

Madewell

All ratings26,316 ratings
Positive93.7%
Neutral2.1%
Negative4.2%
Written reviews200 reviews
Positive10.5%
Neutral10.0%
Negative79.5%

User reviews

Nuuly

From 32K App Store ratings

What we love

  • 🚀 Great service and clothing selection
  • 👍 Convenient and easy to use
  • 💡 Allows trying new styles without commitment
  • 🌱 Eco-friendly and sustainable
  • 🤩 Elevates personal style and confidence

Room to improve

  • 🐛 Quality control issues with damaged or worn items
  • ⏱️ Slow shipping and long wait times
  • 🤔 Limited inventory and item availability
  • 📝 Inconsistent customer service experience
  • 🔍 Buggy and glitchy app interface

Madewell

From 26K App Store ratings

What we love

  • 💻 Great styles
  • 🛒 Convenient app for shopping

Room to improve

  • 🐛 Glitchy and buggy app
  • 🔍 Inconsistent filtering and search
  • 🔑 Login and account issues
  • 🛒 Cart and order issues
  • 🔍 Slow loading and performance

Bugs and requests

Nuuly

Reported bugs

4 issues
  • App crashes and freezes
  • Images and content not loading properly
  • Losing place when navigating back in the app
  • Inconsistent behavior across web and mobile platforms

Requested features

5 requests
  • Ability to exchange or return individual items
  • More detailed size and fit information
  • Waitlist or notification system for out-of-stock items
  • Improved search and filtering capabilities
  • Ability to save and organize items in custom closets

Madewell

Reported bugs

4 issues
  • App freezes and crashes
  • Items disappear from cart
  • Rewards not applying correctly
  • Inconsistent login experience

Requested features

4 requests
  • Sync app and website data
  • Improve account management
  • Streamline checkout process
  • Enhance filtering and search

In-app purchases

None

Nuuly

No in-app purchases

None

Madewell

No in-app purchases

Questions

Is Nuuly free?
Nuuly is free to download, with no in-app purchases.
Is Madewell free?
Madewell is free to download, with no in-app purchases.
Which has better reviews, Nuuly or Madewell?
Nuuly is rated higher. Nuuly averages 4.9 out of 5 from 32K ratings, while Madewell averages 4.8 from 26K ratings.
Do Nuuly or Madewell have ads?
Madewell shows ads; Nuuly does not.
Which is updated more often, Nuuly or Madewell?
Nuuly ships an update every 9 days, and Madewell fortnightly. Most recently, Nuuly was updated on November 16, 2026 and Madewell on November 16, 2026.

Other comparisons