Lemonade Insurance Reviews: Is It Legit?

Customer Experience

Positive experience29.4% of reviews
Neutral3.3% of reviews
Negative experience67.2% of reviews

~ Based on 717 written reviews from the US App Store.

What users say about Lemonade Insurance

Is Lemonade Insurance Safe?

Lemonade Insurance appears safe based on user ratings. AppsHunter Safety Score for Lemonade Insurance is 97/100.

This assessment is based on 86,219 user ratings, with an App Store average of 4.8/5.

Safety Analysis

96.5% of ratings point to a safe experience
0.9% of ratings suggest some concerns
2.6% of ratings point to a risky experience

~ Based on 86,150 App Store ratings for Lemonade Insurance.

Is Lemonade Insurance Legit?

Lemonade Insurance appears to be a legitimate app. AppsHunter Legitimacy Score for Lemonade Insurance is 93/100.

Based on 93 of 100 points across 7 verification signals from App Store and developer data.

Top reviews

App is better than pet insurance

Only thing that’s worse than the app is their insurance. I was denied teeth cleaning. because there’s tartar on their teeth from the last time. I promptly canceled their insurance. It’s cheaper to pay out of pocket than deal with their bs. Their insurance is not a lifesaver, A vet is. Take the money you can save on the insurance and put it in the bank. Use as an emergency fund.
Show more

Pet coverage

I don’t recommend I had another insurance this insurance doesn’t really offer anything like 24 hour vet assistance and the coverage looks great but the claims are not as easy or fast to do they make you add it all the notes take really long to review your claim doesn’t really review it that good and just a lot of back and forth had it for about two years already and can’t wait to end this second year definitely don’t plan on coming back here also adding a pet on your policy doesn’t give u a small discount they just spike the pricing up and act like you get a discount
Show more

Avoid Lemonade Pet Insurance!

After 3 years, my premium went from $43 to $60, and now to $126.71/month for ONE cat! Yet a brand-new quote is still around $48/month!
I’ve only filed one claim and even had to fight to get it covered. Thousands paid in premiums, barely anything reimbursed, and now they more than double my rate!
Terrible way to treat loyal customers. Extremely disappointed. Never again!
And, please!!! Do not believe their generic response about “vet bills getting higher”, nothing changes, especially knowing that new quote costs twice cheaper !!!!
Show more

Bad experince with app and support

Tried this for a year for pet insurance, moved to a different company due to them charging me 2 times for 1 pet and claiming I have 2. Not paying claims out when they say they did. I got fed up after I couldn't submit something and cancelled early to move companies and that one has been 1000 times easier to use and I'm not waiting 3 months for a refund
Show more

The app showed no claims after I submitted one

When your dog or family pet is hurt, you want to know where your claim stands so you can plan for their care. I had to chase down an answer. Lemonade told me over the phone after a long hold there was a denial, but I never received a written decision explaining after no issues with previous emails and submitting was easy.

-July 27, 2026 – Penelope’s Lemonade policy began
-October 13 – I noticed her suddenly limping on her left hand leg.
-October 21 – her vet veterinarian recorded that history, described left knee ligament tear as very acute and noted arthritis on the left knee x-Ray
-October 21. – started the claim with Lemonade
-October 26. Lemonade confirmed the preapproval request by email, said I’d be notified when the review was complete and was directed to the app for updates.
- October 30 – I no longer see the preapproval request in the app. The app also shows no claims have been submitted, even though I submitted a claim for her left knee.
-November 4 – called Lemonade to find out the status via phone because of not being able to check for any updates and have not received any emails after the preapproval was submitted on October 26. In the phone call that involved a denial of the because of a pre-existing condition and awaiting.. My follow up emails were unanswered, and I hadn’t received a written decision telling me whether Lemonade denied the preapproval request, the claim or both.

I have filed complaints at the BBB, the department of insurance, Roto review on trust pilot.

Then, when I tried to cancel the policy, the warning left me, unsure and upset. It stated that if I wanted to get insurance for Penelope again, she would be uninsurable through Lemonade and other insurers.

I understand that insurance can deny a claim. I expected to be able to see what I submitted, read the decision, and know how to ask for another review. If needed. When you are ready, worried about your Dog having to chase down information add stress at the exact moment where you’re looking for clarity.

I would never recommend Lemonade to anyone after this experience.
Show more

App not working

I am trying to see the details of my insurance that I got two days ago and everything was working just fine, though now that I want to view it all I get is a message saying “something went wrong”. Everything else on the app seems to work just fine except for the details on my insurance. Will change my review rating if I see it get fixed. Unfortunately this problem has been happening since last night 11/03/26.
Show more

Bad, slow service

All insurance companies suck, lemonade just has cuter branding.

Neutral

Right now I’m neutral. Just got a text (with a link) asking for more info ; and it sent me to the App Store? I obviously have the App Store- so what’s up?

Cancelled without no explanation.

Don’t waste your time

A promise

Lemonade easily approved my first claim with them. When it came to the second they felt it was their mission to run my dog through the gauntlet of records. They asked for and demanded records when my dog was not insured by them. Absolutely baffling and insanely frustrating.

I don’t write reviews

I don’t really write reviews but I want to tell everyone to cancel whatever insurance you have and go with lemonade,

When my apartment burned down they even voided 3k they were supposed to keep and gave me the full amount amount of the policy,

I had a car crash and they handle everything.

They are the best insurance ever,
And even if you are not in good standing with them they will still protect you.

Lemonade is the best
Show more

Disappointed

I have the pet insurance and I have been so disappointed with the service. I took my dog to the vet for a stomach issue. They still haven’t paid the claim after almost two weeks. My other insurance was a bit more but their turnaround was quick and efficient. Just a heads up.

Horrible experience

This was a horrible experience. I had to take my cat to the ER back in July for an almost blocked bladder so I decided to get insurance so I wouldn’t have to pay out of pocket again. Did everything I was told to make sure he was healthy and wouldn’t happen again. 2 months ago by and he had to be taken again to the ER and this time was fully blocked having to pay $2400 for a weekend to get him healthy. Tried to file a claim and he was not eligible for the refund for a “pre existing” condition. If the condition is common in most young male cats and he could get it again all of his life how am I supposed to then get coverage if that randomly happen does not qualify as illness and also not routine. They were not helpful in hearing me out or understanding at all with the issue. 0/10 recommend.
Show more

Best experience for insurance, period

So easy to get, use, and pay for… makes all other insurance options seem outdated and… just flat out not good

Pet insurance

So I’m not very happy about this insurance and had to cancel because they expect for you to send a full blown report including lab and blood work on your pets health for the year prior to make sure you pet doesn’t have any underlying issues which means they want you to pay out of pocket (even if your pet shows zero symptoms and is healthy and passes health check at vet ) - I understand them requiring a vet visit and getting a checkup but I find that having all these unnecessary tests done completely ridiculous especially when they don’t make this clear right off the bat. Right after the waiting period ended I got a notice saying I needed to upload documents for each one of my best showing literally all tests under the sun lol - this is a scam
Show more

Claim screen gets stuck, no support

I tried submitting a claim two weeks ago and it got stuck in the middle of the process. I reached out to support three weeks ago and I haven’t heard from them apart for a confirmation that they got my message when I first submitted the issue!

Great insurance but system broken

The coverage is great but I’ve made three claims and each time it was a lot of time and effort getting the claims submitted via the app which is the only way to do it. It takes a lot of time to sort the issue out. Then it takes 24-48 hours for them to call back. Also, the checks took a long time. I also shared the link with a friend who signed up. I’m supposed to get a small gift for that. It didn’t process. I’m frustrated. I spent 30 minutes on the phone this morning sorting it all out. Welcome to our automated future.
Show more

Phone only

Won’t let you submit a claim on your computer where all the receipts are sent. Instead you have to save them to your phone and upload them. So annoying.

Pet insurance review

I purchased Lemonade Pet Insurance for my dog Kismet in good faith to cover unexpected illnesses. In August 2026 Kismet was diagnosed with allergic dermatitis and bacterial folliculitis requiring multiple vet visits, Cytopoint injections, prescription antibiotics, medicated shampoos, and a specialized diet. The costs have been significant and ongoing.

Lemonade denied my claim citing a routine wellness visit from December 2025 as a preexisting condition. However at that visit no diagnosis was made, no treatment was prescribed, no diagnostics were ordered, and the veterinarian noted no physical findings consistent with allergies. Mild itchiness was briefly mentioned in passing among many possible causes. The treating veterinarian provided a detailed letter confirming this explicitly.

Despite submitting a formal appeal with supporting veterinary documentation, Lemonade upheld their denial. I have since filed a complaint with the New York State Department of Financial Services.

I chose Lemonade specifically to have coverage for situations exactly like this. A casual mention of mild scratching during a wellness visit being used to deny months of serious medical treatment is not what I understood I was purchasing. I would caution other pet owners to carefully review how Lemonade defines preexisting conditions before purchasing a policy.
Show more

RUN AWAY

Don’t purchase this insurance. Super expensive, any other insurances are way more affordable, it’s 100$ for every 350 miles driven ish… on top of base pay 120$…