Comparison

Milford vs Smartly

Price, ratings, monetisation and update history for both apps, side by side — with what reviewers say about each.

Head to head
About

Milford

Manage your investments with ease. Track your balance, view personalized performance, and see where your money is invested. Access transaction history, reports, and statements all in one place.

Highlights
  • View account balance
  • Personalized performance tracking
  • Investment allocation overview
  • Transaction history
  • Access reports and statements
Features
Read full description

Milford's Mobile App makes it easy to keep track of your investments. You can see your balance, personalised performance and where your money is invested. You can also easily view your transaction history and access reports and statements.

About

Smartly

This app allows employees to manage their payroll information, including viewing payslips, applying for leave, and submitting timesheets. Employers must set up employee accounts for access. It simplifies payroll management for both employees and businesses.

Highlights
  • View payslips
  • Apply for leave
  • Submit timesheets
  • Track leave balances
  • Assign hours to jobs
  • Email PDF payslips
Features
Read full description

The Smartly mobile app is for employees who work for a business that uses Smartly to manage their payroll. As an employee you can check your pay history and apply for leave as well as submit timesheets. To login, your employer needs to set you up in the payroll site and give you your username. You’ll then get an email to create your password and you’ll be good to go! FEATURES Pay details - View your payslips (up to 3 months). - Email yourself a PDF version of your payslip. - See a countdown to your next pay. Managing leave requests - Apply for leave (including special leave types). - View any upcoming leave, plus leave history and balances. - Managers can add, edit, approveor decline leave requests for their team. - View future leave balances when applying for leave. Submitting timesheets - Enter time and rate per hour. - Create multiple time entries for each day. - Managers can add, edit, approve or decline time for their team. - Remembers the last timesheet entry and prefills the same hours. - Copy a previous weeks timesheet to save time. Labour costing - Assign hours worked to different jobs or departments. ABOUT SMARTLY We know that payroll can be a headache. So, at Smartly we make it simple for businesses to pay their people on time, accurately and in-line with regulation. Faff-free payroll, happy staff, no headaches. Too easy!

Screenshots

Milford4 screens
Smartly4 screens

Verdict

The call

The clearest difference is rating: Smartly at 4.8 against Milford's 3.4. Smartly also leads on ratings volume (36 vs 5). Milford's advantage is review sentiment (40% vs 32%). On price, update cadence, ads and in-app purchases there is nothing between them.

Scored on Price · Rating · Positive reviews · Number of ratings · Update frequency · Ads · In-app purchases · Monetization · Best chart rank · Devices · Requires iOS

CostPrice · In-app purchases · Ads · Monetization

Both are free to download. Neither carries in-app purchases, so what you see is what you pay.

ReceptionRating · Positive reviews · Number of ratings

Smartly holds the better App Store score, 4.8 against 3.4. That said, the two scores are not equally well evidenced: Smartly has 36 ratings behind it against 5, so its average is the more settled of the two. Written reviews complicate that: 40% of Milford's written reviews are positive against 32% of Smartly's, so the app with the better star average is not the one people write more warmly about.

UpkeepUpdate frequency

Milford ships an update every 6 weeks, Smartly monthly. The most recent releases landed on November 3, 2026 and November 14, 2026 respectively.

Scorecard3 real differences · 7 level
Milford versus Smartly: the parameters behind the verdict, then further details
ParameterMilfordSmartly
PriceFreeFree
Rating3.4 (5 ratings)4.8 (36 ratings) — better
Positive reviews40.0% of reviews — better31.9% of reviews
Number of ratings536 — better
Update frequencyEvery 6 weeksMonthly — better
AdsNoNo
In-app purchasesNoNo
MonetizationFreeFree
DevicesiPhone, iPadiPhone, iPod
Requires iOS16.415.1 — better
Further details — not scored
Size115 MB24 MB
Age rating4+4+
DeveloperMilford Asset Management LimitedSmartPayroll

Customer experience

Milford

All ratings5 ratings
Positive40.0%
Neutral40.0%
Negative20.0%
Written reviews45 reviews
Positive40.0%
Neutral13.3%
Negative46.7%

Smartly

All ratings35 ratings
Positive97.1%
Neutral0.0%
Negative2.9%
Written reviews69 reviews
Positive31.9%
Neutral14.5%
Negative53.6%

User reviews

Milford

From 5 App Store ratings

What we love

  • 👍 Easy to use
  • 👍 Simple and easy to use
  • 👍 Good dashboard information
  • 👍 Easy to login with biometrics or pin
  • 👍 Can see balance easy on dashboard

Room to improve

  • 🐛 App not opening
  • 🐛 White screen
  • 🐛 Portal broken
  • 🐛 Always crash
  • 🐛 Terrible 2 factor implementation

Smartly

From 36 App Store ratings

What we love

  • 👍 Easy to use
  • 👍 Intuitive design
  • 👍 Straightforward
  • 👍 Good for tracking shifts
  • 👍 Great for employees

Room to improve

  • 🐛 Constantly logs out
  • 🐛 Frequent login issues
  • 🐛 App crashes/freezes
  • 🐛 Slow performance
  • 🐛 Poor accessibility

Bugs and requests

Milford

Reported bugs

65 issues
  • App not opening, white screen
  • Portal broken
  • Always crashing
  • Terrible 2 factor implementation
  • Facial recognition removed every few logins
Show 60 more
  • PIN incorrect after facial recognition issues
  • All information lost after PIN issues
  • No biometric security
  • Account performance takes forever to load
  • Gap on left side of hamburger menu
  • Profile icon but can't change photo
  • Way too many updates
  • Constantly in maintenance
  • App crashes when it opens
  • Haven't been able to log in for a month
  • Always crashing
  • Always getting new updates
  • Needs much improvement
  • Logged out completely, need full username/password
  • Face ID/PIN doesn't work
  • Tools & Calculators menu item disappearing
  • Forecast My Balance calculator full of bugs
  • Never been able to access information
  • Stuck with setup login details
  • Not possible to logout and login with alternative details
  • Unused friendly
  • Updates every week
  • Frustrating frequent updates
  • Minor changes with frequent updates
  • Many bugs
  • Customer experience not highest priority
  • Often under maintenance
  • No customer feedback mechanisms
  • App is the weakest link
  • Have to kill app after maintenance mode
  • Frequent updates make app unusable
  • Forces auto updates mid-transaction
  • Disappointing
  • Doesn't do landscape orientation on iPad
  • iPad version no longer works in wide screen mode
  • Widescreen mode no longer works on iPad
  • Error occurred, won't let you log in
  • Collects data from iOS clipboard
  • Lazy programming or data collection tactic
  • App crashes five to ten seconds after loading
  • Continuously glitches
  • Forgets password after a few days
  • Fingerprint ID doesn't work
  • Hard to use when you can't log in
  • Requires login every day
  • No username and password saved
  • Hunt for username and password again every day
  • Very annoying login
  • Periodically requires random username re-entry
  • Keeps losing login details
  • Crash a couple times lately
  • Logs out session
  • Prompts to set up 4 digit pin plus Touch ID
  • Not prompting for authenticator code
  • Allowed to log in with only credentials without authenticator code
  • Security issue, could log in without MFA
  • Authenticator no longer asked for
  • Blank home screen
  • No transaction or account data pulled through
  • Crashes when tapping several links

Requested features

8 requests
  • Passkey option
  • Dark mode
  • Landscape orientation on iPad
  • Wide screen mode on iPad
  • Customer feedback mechanisms in the app
Show 3 more
  • Live feed for copy changes
  • Option to choose Authenticator app type
  • Switch preference to SMS OTP

Smartly

Reported bugs

39 issues
  • Notifications don't work
  • App size increased
  • Biometrics enrollment repeated
  • Password reset issues
  • Login button unresponsive
Show 34 more
  • Keeps logging out
  • App crashes or freezes
  • Date selection hard
  • App crashes or freezes regularly
  • Issues with shifts past midnight
  • Cannot log in
  • App freezes when adding timesheet
  • Timesheet tab buffering
  • App doesn't function
  • Cannot approve timesheets
  • Randomly logs out users
  • App crashes every fortnight
  • Slow to respond to taps
  • App freezes on loading screen
  • Cannot add timesheet when logged in
  • Timesheet tab buffering and error
  • App won't function
  • Cannot approve timesheets
  • Randomly logs out
  • App crashes every fortnight
  • Slow to respond
  • App crashes
  • App crashes immediately
  • App hangs on white loading screen
  • Login issues
  • App doesn't remember login
  • Constant lag and freezing
  • Screens don't allow scrolling
  • New timesheet layout doesn't let you copy hours
  • App needs to be repeatedly reinstalled
  • App doesn't open
  • App crashes
  • App crashes immediately
  • App hangs on white loading screen

Requested features

10 requests
  • Ability to put in start time without finish time
  • Reminder for missing finish time
  • More detailed app
  • Web portal access for employees
  • Ability to handle working past midnight without two entries
Show 5 more
  • Export staff on leave to Outlook calendar
  • Ability to put time to time in lieu
  • Previous week preloaded
  • Auto-save start and finish times from previous day
  • Notifications

In-app purchases

None

Milford

No in-app purchases

None

Smartly

No in-app purchases

Questions

Is Milford free?
Milford is free to download, with no in-app purchases.
Is Smartly free?
Smartly is free to download, with no in-app purchases.
Which has better reviews, Milford or Smartly?
Smartly is rated higher. Milford averages 3.4 out of 5 from 5 ratings, while Smartly averages 4.8 from 36 ratings.
Do Milford or Smartly have ads?
Neither Milford nor Smartly shows ads.
Which is updated more often, Milford or Smartly?
Milford ships an update every 6 weeks, and Smartly monthly. Most recently, Milford was updated on November 3, 2026 and Smartly on November 14, 2026.

Other comparisons