Sheetz Food Delivery & Rewards User Reviews

Customer Experience

Positive experience44.2% of reviews
Neutral7.9% of reviews
Negative experience47.9% of reviews

~ Based on 606 written reviews from the US App Store.

What users say

Is Sheetz Food Delivery & Rewards Safe?

Sheetz Food Delivery & Rewards appears safe based on user ratings. AppsHunter Safety Score for Sheetz Food Delivery & Rewards is 96/100.

This assessment is based on 92,743 user ratings, with an App Store average of 4.8/5.

Safety Analysis

96.0% of ratings point to a safe experience
1.5% of ratings suggest some concerns
2.6% of ratings point to a risky experience

~ Based on 92,743 App Store ratings for Sheetz Food Delivery & Rewards.

Is Sheetz Food Delivery & Rewards Legit?

Sheetz Food Delivery & Rewards appears to be a legitimate app. AppsHunter Legitimacy Score for Sheetz Food Delivery & Rewards is 83/100.

Based on 83 of 100 points across 7 verification signals from App Store and developer data.

Top reviews

Almost never get my order

I’ve used the app multiple times and probably 75% I never receive my order and it gets canceled! There is no way to track my order on the app either, so after waiting several hours then I receive a message letting me know my order was canceled. I have no confidence I’ll ever receive what I order when using this app.
Show more

Family Style Vibes

Super kindness from JD & Shawn & Tehran. Everyone is genuinely smiling and helpful. I enjoy my experience while at Sheetz.

Weird payment system

I could not figure out how to use a regular credit card. They wanted me to set up a Sheetz card, which is something I don’t want to do. If you can pay by regular credit card in the store, you should be able to do so on the app. Immediate uninstall.

Can’t order

The error “Oh sheetz!“ pops up every time i enter the menu to order. Everything else in the app works fine, minus ordering. What’s the point of the app then?

Service

Rude. Customer service is dead.

Payment

It was way to hard to pay I had to keep going back to my wallet and then back to the order and then back to my wallet and back to the order I should give you zero stars, but that’s an option

Drinks

I was buying 4 drinks & wanted 2 cups of ice 1 for myself & 1 for my husband I had told them he had already been in there paid for some items & gas they told me only 1 cup of ice per customer. That is crazy if I’m buying 1 for my husband & one for myself.

BETTER THAN WAWA

Of course as we all know very well, SHEETZ blows wawa out of the water I mean “wooter” as they pronounce it on the east side of the state.

Works well, but limits on food customization is frustrating

Still hoping the option for omitting extra salt on foods will be added. Until then, can’t give this 5 stars.

I can’t track my delivery order

If I use the delivery part of the app, I can only guess when it’s being delivered and when it has arrived. I would turn on notifications but I only want them when I order. Not constant solicitations.

Can not check in for curb side

If I ask someone to pick up my order, they can’t because I am not physically there, how does that make sense? Curb side is the best thing since sliced bread, I only order curb side, but what if I have someone pick up my order? And I can’t even check in to have the app function accordingly?

Yah

Bro fabulous

A Friendly Oasis: Sheetz in Plum Borough Shines Bright! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

I absolutely love my visits to Sheetz at 950 Presque Isle Dr. in Plum Borough! This location is not just about convenience; it's truly a hidden gem thanks to its amazing employees. Every time I walk in, I’m greeted by smiling faces and friendly hellos that instantly brighten my day. The team goes above and beyond to make sure every customer feels welcome and valued. Whether I'm grabbing a quick snack or filling up my tank, their positive attitudes make the experience so enjoyable. Plus, the place is always clean and well-organized. If you’re in the area, do yourself a favor and stop by! You won’t just leave with a tasty treat, but also with a smile from the wonderful staff!
Show more

Owner

Excellent drive thru service - markedly

It’s not like Sheetz that we use to know

they must work more on their professional development

SHEETZ FREAK

I LOVE THEM. 24/7 Like Come On. Nothing Better Than a 2AM Trip 😉

Hopeful, But disappointed

I’ve tried to do online gas payments several times at sheetz. Using the Pump & Pay option I failed to pump gas due to the required 175 minimum balance for the hold. When using the Wawa app and rewards I’ve had no problems paying with under the hold amount.

21+ verification does NOT work

It asks you to enter your details and then fails the verification everytime. All of my info is correct. Why wouldn’t they just have an option to upload your ID? There’s no other way to bypass it other than sitting on hold for hours (like I’m currently doing) with customer service. I love sheetz but this is really annoying. Why have the feature if it’s not going to work anyway
Show more

Order options

On some of the items, like the salads, I think you should be able to customize them to your liking, you are able to do that in the store. But when you are on your 30 min lunch break, you do not have time to go in the store to place your order.

Very slow

Why can’t it just go ti next instead of circling and thinking?