Does not work for carnivore
Getting worse and worse
When adding saved foods there is now a meal filter that was added, but evidently was developed in such a way that no foods saved before that filter was added are tagged with a meal. This means that every time I log food I have an extra, pointless step now to select “all meals” from this filter. It seems small but if the developers actually used this app every day they would realize how much friction this adds up to.
And don’t get me started on “autopilot” which I am prompted to try out every single day and there is no way to hide it. If the developers actually used the app to track macros (for example, with a nutrition coach) then they would understand that having an AI model adjust my macros all the time is the dumbest idea anyone has ever cooked up.
Response from developer
Hi Ryan, Thanks for your review. You’re right that we missed the mark on filtering recents by meal. Before shipping it we let recents by meal history accrue for one week but evidently this was not enough time to make the default meal filter be helpful because there wasn’t enough historical data. As a result, next week we’ll be reverting the default meal filter back to “All meals” and giving users the option to change their default meal filter value if they wish. Regarding Autopilot, what you saw is the one-time set-up wizard that guides you through migrating from the old Daily Goals to the new Nutrition Plan method of managing your daily targets. After snoozing it 3 times, completing the migration wizard is required. Your new Nutrition Plan can have exactly the same targets as your current Goal(s) has so nothing changes there. The only difference is how and where you manage your plan moving forward. Once you finish the migration wizard you can continue using MacrosFirst just as you always have. Opting into Autopilot, in which your targets automatically update following a weekly check-in, is entirely optional and not required. Also Autopilot is not AI. It is an algorithmic approach to calculating your expenditure and nutrition targets built upon validated, peer-reviewed models of human metabolism published by the NIH and other research institutions. There is zero AI in Autopilot and Copilot. If you have questions you can reach us at hello@macrosfirst.com or from live chat at More > Contact Us. Best, -JB (834 day streaker)
Clunky, stupid app
2. Copying only allows copying entire meals instead of individual foods (which you might want because the app makes you rescan each food for every single meal the first time you log it).
3. Copying entire days worth of meals (because you’re dealing with problems 1 and 2) has no confirmation prompt and no undo action, utterly nuking your entry for the day.
MyFitnessPal after the updates is annoying, Macro Factor is ugly and bland to look at, but this is the only app that has destroy my records of an entire day’s worth of logging because so many basic intuitive actions aren’t there.













